RV Blog Hirst: Aid Package is More Stabilization than Stimulus

Hirst: Aid Package is More Stabilization than Stimulus

Your Real Vision Daily Briefing for March 26, 2020

Ed & Roger comment on the rally in equities in light of the recently passed American stimulus package and the record-breaking jobless claims numbers.

  • The recently passed American stimulus package may be more of an offset than an additive, according to Real Vision’s Ed Harrison and Roger Hirst.
  • Targeting the right parts of the economy at the right time is critical, and in terms of lost output the relief package is only filling a hole that’s already been dug. They said the long-term impact could be deflationary. 
  • As investors grasp the fundamentals of the real economy, they expect the future market to shift away from passive investing. 


Get the latest information as we analyze the next phase of our new global economy and discuss what we think is to come.

Now that the market has weathered an initial deleveraging stage in the past week, we’re moving into a crisis based on the fundamentals of the real economy over the next 2-3 months, said Ed Harrison and Roger Hirst on today’s Real Vision Daily Briefing.

They said the size of the recently passed stimulus, though massive, is not likely to restore the market to its pre-pandemic form. Hirst said timing will play a critical role in the success of the Fed’s efforts going forward.

“The key is targeting and timing. Will they aim the bazooka in the right place at the right time?”

While in the short term the stimulus may create inflationary bottlenecks, Hirst and Harrison think the effects over the long term will be profoundly deflationary – particularly as companies and individuals not covered by the stimulus eschew expensive capital.

“Now we’re moving to a crisis based on the fundamentals of the real economy,” Harrison said. With the fundamentals as bad as they are, he said it sets the market up for another swing down when people start to understand where the real economy is.

“The downdraft and the snapback have been so large that realized volatility is still high,” said Harrison. “When equities fall again there’s still going to be a sell signal on [passively managed] funds and that is going to accelerate the next down draft that we see.”

Hirst believes this will eventually play out as a shift away from passive investing. He envisions a future model where active managers are back in the driving seat and emotions and valuations will become relevant again.